The In-your-face chase

dbasso's picture

When writing a resume according to all the suggestions that were given from the readings, I thought that it was very challenging. I thought that writing a cover letter would be different but after reading the recommendations for writing a cover letter it feels the same as writing a resume. The document definitely feels like the shape of a technical document with distinct portions like an introduction, body, and conclusion. Even though it must be short and concise, a cover letter must represent a lot of information including background, skills, and even attitude. When reading the “Kairos and the Cover Letter “ I thought that the “In your face approach” was not appropriate way write a cover letter. It seemed too much of a cocky approach. I really thought that the “Me approach” was the best way to write a cover letter. It had all the background and information that the employer needed to confidently give a interview. I have never written a cover letter but will probably use the “Me approach”.

Knowing that a resume can ruin the chances of getting your resume reviewed, it seems risky even writing one. Giving a resume and maybe a follow up letter seems efficient enough for me. Explained in the “Junk Cover Letters Kill Good Resumes” article the job market is not a jobseekers market anymore and cover letters are becoming more important. It is understandable that cover letters are more important because choosing out of twenty people by just looking at their resumes would be a very hard thing to do. With a cover letter, a Human Resources worker can get more of a feel on how the applicant is really like. Even though some people have more experience or a higher GPA, a person’s cover letter might distinguish them from more qualified people.

In Your Face

jrdavies's picture

The "in your face" approach was definitely inappropriate. Companies do not want to hire cocky employees. The father of a brother in my fraternity was offering job interviews to other brothers, but the company's interviewer came across a particularly cocky individual through this process. He embarrassed both our house and the man who had referred him. They haven't asked for any more people since. I'm not so sure that the "me" approach is good either. The end of the article states that "Each of the four openings shows someone more bent on emulating a style than on speaking to a real person hiring for this position." I think the author is trying to show us that you must write a letter that conveys genuine personality while also highlighting personal skills that will benefit the company.

First Impression of Personality

Ben's picture

I agree as well. The "in your face" example seemed excessively arrogant, to the point that I cannot imagine anyone seriously sending a cover letter with that type of tone. Especially for entry level jobs, cockiness to this degree would be extremely detrimental. Jrdavies, I think you nailed it to a tee, when you said that the author is suggesting that we write our cover letters in a tone that reflects our genuine personalities. The cover letter is the only document that allows recruiters, who have not met you, to see what your personality is like. So while writing your cover letter, it is important to keep in mind that you might be giving others a first impression of your personality.

Bad Examples

Nathaniel's picture

Do revisit the "Kairos and the Cover Letter" reading to discover that several of the examples were explicitly offered as bad examples.